Order Your Lucille's Pies

Whether Stopping for Breakfast Or Lunch,

You Should Try The Pie!

It's Part Of Why We Are On

The Anthony Bourdain Food Trail.

Our Fresh Baked Pies Are Available To Order Ahead

All Orders Must Be Picked Up At Our Location

1496 Rt. 539 Warren Grove, Stafford Twp. NJ

All Pie Orders Must Be Picked Up By 2pm

Keep In Mind - We Are Not Open On Mondays

Online Ordering For Christmas
2025 Is Now Open

If Ordering More Than 5 Pies
Call Or Stop By In Person

As Always We Will Have A Selection Of Pies Available For Grab And Go Sales At The Counter

Apple

Blueberry

Cherry

Coconut Custard

Fruits Of The Forest

Lemon Meringue

Peach

Pecan

Pumpkin

Strawberry Rhubarb

Apple Raspberry

Cranberry Apple